Why financial market short selling is unfair to the majority of investors
The news gracing the pages of papers and internet sites all over the world during the last six months and most definitely over the last couple, more so than famine, war and all the other 'usual' items deemed worthy of news is that of the financial markets. Everyday the media looks to sensationalise events, oil up or down, mortgages failing or not, banking system collapse etc....but there is also talk about the impact of short selling and impact it has on the direction of the market and the wealth reallocation amongst individuals.
Like many of us who understand or at least pretend to understand the financial markets, main ones being the Dow, FTSE, Hang Seng, Nikkei, we probably tend to agree with a nod of our heads that short selling has its benefits. It was meant to allow a short-term hedge on a long position, whether physical or synthetic or likewise would be used to call-out companies that weren't so strong financially as they seemed. Hedge funds, short sellers continue to stick with this line that they are doing the world a favour by short selling all these stocks to 40, 50, or even 90% of it's current market value. Well if they count the world as their investors I guess they have it right.
The part I would have an issue with from a moral perspective is that many funds, and thus normal investors/the rest of us, are not allowed to short stock and must via mandate hold certain percentages of shares in the major indexes. Pension funds, mutual funds etc are not as flexible in terms of investment strategy as any hedge fund, specialist asset manager or even day trader with a margin account. So this means the majority of the population loses wealth which is re-allocated to the minority of the population who are able to invest this way.
Whilst the losing mutual and pension funds gain a small return by lending stock to the short sellers, who cares when they lose in excess of 50% of the fund's value in that stock. Particularly, as one piece of research shows, fund managers generally have little of their personal wealth in their own funds. Meaning they are not losing their money, but that of their investors.
So until the rules change that permit anyone to short sell the financial market playing field is stacked against the average everyday investor. My advice; learn to invest on your own terms and take your money out of any fund that is not flexible in respect to investment strategy. The writing on the wall says that long only funds will not continue to do well as the market will not automatically continue to rise - therefore short sellers will rule the market. Knowing this don't just sit on your hands and hope for the best. Act today and take your financial well being into your own hands
Labels: financial planning, investing, market plunges, short selling

